 Having spent many years as a Senior International Recruitment Consultant at SmartRecruitment.com, I’ve had the privilege of connecting with diverse talent from across the globe (quite literally – Asia, Europe, North America, Africa, LATAM and Oceania!) Throughout my journey, one pivotal piece of the recruitment process always rings true – providing a good candidate experience leads to better overall results, not only from a candidate standpoint but also for the company involved in the hiring process. Irrespective of the region you’re hiring in or the level of seniority the role plays in an organization, a poor candidate experience doesn’t just cost you one hire but can damage your employer brand. In our ever-evolving, fast-moving business world —where competition for top talent is fierce— candidates remember how they are treated and a negative interaction can spread quickly through industry circles, making it harder to attract the right people in the future. But, what is a great candidate experience? It’s not just about being nice. It’s about setting the right expectations, respecting candidates’ time, and making sure the hiring process is as smooth and engaging as possible. Of course, recruitment is still very much a “human” job (as much as AI might want to disagree!), so naturally, there will be moments where we forget to reply to a message or forgo an update. However, I believe that enhancing candidate experience whenever possible will always yield beneficial results and be crucial for an organization's overall success. A little goes a long way when it comes to candidate experience. Let’s take a look into why this matters and what we, as recruiters, can do to try and get it “right”. 1. First Contact: Setting the Tone The initial interaction lays the foundation for the candidate's perception of the company that is hiring and the role at hand. In the early days, my outreach emails were generic, leading to lukewarm responses. Recognizing this, I started crafting personalized messages that highlight specific aspects of the candidate's background aligning with the roles that I’d have available. For instance, when reaching out to a game developer with a passion for innovative design, I referenced their recent project that caught my attention. This tailored approach led to an increase in positive responses, underscoring the power of personalization. I also find better engagement when my initial reachout messages are ‘short and sweet’, making sure to address the individual by name and ending with a follow up question in order to prompt a reply. Candidates on Linkedin are constantly being bombarded with job suggestions, so they do not have all the time in the world to discern which are the most suitable for them. Thus, keeping your initial outreach direct and relevant to their background is key to attracting attention. Personally, I find that long, drawn out messages come off robotic and AI written, which would cause the reader to quickly disengage. 2. Interviews: Creating a Comfortable Environment Great, you finally caught the candidates attention and they want to interview with you and/or the hiring company! Interviews can be daunting, and it's our responsibility to ensure candidates feel at ease to showcase their true potential. Ignoring the human side and treating candidates like transactions is a top blunder that many fall victim to in the hiring process. I recall a situation where a highly qualified candidate was very excited for a role but when he finished the last round, his response was lackluster at best. I reached out to the interview panel for feedback. I discovered that they misunderstood one portion of a candidates’ reply and instead of asking for clarification, they decided to abruptly end the conversation. To help this, we implemented interviewer training focusing on active listening and follow up. We also began sharing statistics on how ending interviews early due to pre-assessments could actually end up costing the business more. When certain follow up questions were implemented, it clarified preconceived notions of certain answers a candidate would provide. In the example provided earlier, the candidate aforementioned actually ended up being suitable and not having to interview an entirely new round of candidates from scratch, ended up saving the company’s overall resources in the end, especially the interviewers’ time. 3. Feedback: Timely and Constructive Communication One of the most significant pain points for candidates is the dreaded "black hole" after interviews. Ever heard a candidate say, “I sent my application weeks ago” or “I’ve interviewed weeks ago and I’ve heard nothing”? That’s the dreaded black hole of recruitment. I remember a fantastic Director level candidate who applied for a role with one of my clients in the past. He was left waiting for over three weeks without any update. By the time the company decided to proceed, he had accepted another offer. As a recruiter, it is extremely important to set expectations when you can. Even if there’s no news, a simple and quick update like - “We’re still reviewing applications and will update you by next Friday,” - keeps candidates engaged. Sometimes, you just can’t push the hiring team, whether it be internal or external for a final decision but by keeping the communication open with the candidate, you are at least allowing an option for both parties to know where one another stands. Even when the news is not favorable, providing any feedback, especially constructive feedback helps candidates understand areas for improvement. Even a short note like, “Your experience is great, but we needed someone with deeper regulatory compliance knowledge,” is better than nothing and can make a big difference to candidates in their interview journey. 4. Offer Stage: Transparency and Support Extending an offer is a critical juncture, and clarity is paramount. At the end of the day, we’re not just filling roles—we’re helping people make life-changing career moves. Showing empathy and flexibility when possible to support candidates through the process are very important aspects in the interview process. I remember a candidate that went through many rounds of interviews and was ready to take the offer but when he finished the offer discussion call, he was uncertain. I reached out and discovered that the hiring manager’s demeanor appeared intimidating. The candidate, who initially was excited about the offer, just wanted a few days to discuss relocation with his family. The hiring manager had pressured him for an immediate answer, making him feel uncomfortable. He declined the offer. This prompted us to remind the Hiring Manager that he had overlooked his company’s benefits from relocation assistance to growth opportunities within the team. We also urged him to schedule a face to face meeting with the candidate, emphasizing the importance of not losing out on great talent to competitors. He agreed to do so, which helped ensure the candidate and made them feel valued. The candidate reversed his initial decision and joined the team after all. Conclusion: Improving the candidate experience is an ongoing journey that requires empathy, continuous feedback, and adaptability. By viewing processes through the eyes of the candidates and making thoughtful adjustments, an organization will have an easier time attracting and successfully retaining top talent. The recruitment world is fast paced and these days, many recruiters are highly focused on metrics, data, time to hire, cost per hire, and the ever anxiety of closing roles. We are not going to get it right 100% of the time but what makes us different from machines, is the way in how we approach conversations, sometimes hard ones, with empathy, whenever possible, especially with our candidates. Doing our best to keep up a positive candidate experience through timely feedback, being responsive, remembering check-ins, and treating each individual with respect, will inevitably set the stage for long-term success. If you’re in the hiring space, I’d love to learn and hear from you. What strategies have you implemented to improve the candidate journey? Let's keep improving and growing together. Written by: Christina Rowe Comments are closed.
|